If you’ve spent any time researching selective colleges, you’ve likely encountered the phrase “holistic admissions.” It appears everywhere from websites to information sessions to brochures with suspiciously happy students sitting on campus lawns.
But ask three people to define it, and you’ll likely end up with three very different answers.
So, let’s clear things up. Holistic admissions is real, it’s important, and it’s not (contrary to popular belief) code for “just be yourself and hope for the best.”
Holistic admissions generally means that colleges evaluate the whole applicant rather than relying on a single metric like GPA or test scores. This means schools will look at academics but also activities, character, context, and fit for their specific institution.
It’s not a loophole, and it’s not a mystery. Holistic review is a structured process with a purpose: finding students who will contribute meaningfully to a campus community.
But if you’d like the longer, more helpful version, keep reading.
Picture this: a college receives 40,000 applications and 10,000 of those students have near-perfect GPAs. If admissions were based solely on numbers, every class would look practically the same: excellent test-takers with little room for nuanced strengths or student context.
Now imagine those 10,000 academically stellar applicants are competing for only 3,000 spots. How do Admissions Officers choose between so many students who look nearly identical on paper?!
Holistic review exists because students are more than a transcript. And, frankly, because academics alone don’t give colleges enough information to make thoughtful decisions. Schools want researchers, leaders, artists, coders, caregivers, activists, and even late-bloomers. They’re looking for students who add dimension, not duplication.
Holistic review helps Admissions Officers identify:
In other words, they’re not just asking, “Can you do the work?” They’re also asking, “Who will you be once you’re here? And does that fit with our campus culture and priorities?”
You may have seen lists that include buzzwords like “intellectual curiosity” or “grit,” which sound great in theory but don’t show up on a transcript. So how do colleges evaluate the whole picture in practice?
Here’s the less catchy but more accurate breakdown:
1. Academic Foundation
Grades, rigor, academic trends, teacher comments, and test scores (when submitted). This is still the most important category, but it’s not the only one.
2. Activities and Impact
Notice I didn’t say activities and quantity. Colleges are looking for meaning, initiative, and the ways students have contributed. Whether that’s leading a state-championship robotics team or tutoring a younger sibling every afternoon, the specific activity matters far less than the commitment behind it.
3. Essays
Essays are the closest thing an Admissions Officer has to hearing a student’s actual voice. Holistic review emphasizes essays because they reveal a student’s personality, values, thought process, humor, and growth.
Essays are also the part of the application students have the most control over. They’re often the piece that helps someone genuinely stand out from the pack.
4. Recommendations
Strong letters highlight not just intelligence, but character, collaboration, and classroom presence. A truly glowing recommendation can nudge a borderline applicant into the admit pile, while a weak or negative one can seriously undercut even an academically stellar student.
5. Context
This is the piece families often misunderstand. Context does not mean “special treatment.” It means Admissions Officers interpret a student’s accomplishments in light of the opportunities they did or did not have access to. Two students can demonstrate equal strength while taking very different paths.
Context is what helps an Admissions Officer understand the opportunities available within a specific high school and community. It’s why students in an AP curriculum aren’t compared to those in an IB program. And why a prospective theater student in Texas isn’t expected to have an off-Broadway acting credit. Context is essential for evaluating every student, no matter their background or environment.
6. Personal Qualities
Colleges don’t expect (or want) an “I am a selfless leader with perfect integrity” statement. They’re assessing qualities through patterns: your writing, your actions, your choices, your recommendations.
Holistic review looks for consistency, maturity, curiosity, kindness, initiative, and more. These are all the things that make a student into someone that other people actually want to live and learn with. When I read applications, I’d often find myself asking, “Is this a person I’d want to get lunch with on campus?”
Holistic review can feel mysterious, but when you understand how it works, it becomes empowering. This is because students are not reduced to a number. They have control over their own narrative and can focus on what actually matters to them. Students and families just need to understand how to strategize effectively.
If a student is a late bloomer, a creative thinker, or someone who shines outside the classroom, holistic review provides multiple pathways to stand out.
Holistic review also means depth wins over breadth, authenticity over box-checking, and growth over perfection. Students don’t need to be everything. Rather, they need to be themselves with purpose.
Essays, activities, and recommendations tell a story. When students intentionally shape that narrative, their applications become clearer, stronger, and more memorable.
This is where strong advising comes in. Once you understand what Admissions Officers are looking for, you can make smart choices about courses, activities, summers, essays, and overall application strategy.
Myth: “Holistic admissions means anything goes.”
Fact: No, colleges still care deeply about academics, which is the foundation for the larger application.
Myth: “It’s totally unpredictable.”
Fact: Individual outcomes vary, but the overall application review process is generally consistent, structured, and informed by data.
Myth: “A perfect applicant exists.”
Fact: Admissions Officers do not read with an ideal applicant in mind. There is no specific set of courses or activities that will get a student admitted. Rather, colleges and universities are building a community of interesting, motivated humans. They need scientists and artists, introverts and extraverts, club leaders and club members.
Myth: “I need to do more activities.”
Fact: Most students will benefit from having 2-3 activities that show long-term commitment and intention. Simply adding more activities (typically with less substance) will not overcome deficits in the student’s transcript or writing.
Holistic admissions rewards clarity, strategy, and authenticity. Yet, figuring out how to execute all three requires expertise that students and families aren’t expected to have.
That’s where Infinite Futures comes in.
We help students:
Most importantly, our team of Former Admissions Officers and College Advisors help families replace stress and confusion with a clear, personalized plan.
If you’re ready to navigate holistic admissions with confidence and build an application that truly reflects who you are, schedule a consultation today.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dr. Corinne Smith spent a decade as an undergraduate Admissions Officer for Northwestern University and Yale University. She has also read applications for Brown University and UC San Diego. Corinne has her B.A. and M.S. from Northwestern and received her Doctorate in Education from the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign. At Infinite Futures, she serves as the Director of Application Strategy and oversees the essay editing process for all students.
